Zolton: Nazgul and Butterfangers don't concern themselves much with evidence. Their hypothesis is "supported" by assumptions, their main one being; because there were labor camps along the line west of Treblinka and the eastward bound trains made stops at them, the Jews who got off the tr...

Lamprecht:

I only skimmed the paper because it is completely irrelevant to the topic of this thread

So is Belzec.

Nazgul: There are no known labour camps in the Lviv area. Lutsk is about 140 km away. bombsaway: One of the major problems with your theory is there were labor camps everywhere in Poland, and especially by major ghettos. Nazgul and Butterfangers do not have theory, they have a hypothesis. A theory ...

Nazgul: It has been shown here that there were a large number of labour camps for Jews on the lines heading to Treblinka from both directions. The trains did stop at these camps for extended periods, they also stopped at railway junctions. Question for the serial dodger: Could the existence "of...

bombsaway: another cause for the delays could have been loading up non-employable Jewish "resettlers" from nearby ghettos. Right, because, as Hektor pointed out: Physical removal from society and territory. That's what the NS-policy towards Jews was. Yet Butterfangers alleges: Many or most...

And that this "new information" solves "the looming question of "where did they [Jews] go?". IOW, the answer to the question of "If the Jews weren't murdered at Treblinka II, then were did they go?" is, according to Butterfangers: Somewhere west of Treblinka. Nazg...

borjastick: Removal or expulsion was the programme and the delivery method of the so called 'final solution', a term I would add that was used by the jews themselves prior to all this happening, and no there was no extermination 'pogrom'. HeiligeSturm : Exactly. HeiligeSturm : To the question itsel...

Zolton: borjastick, do you deny that the revisionist thesis on the Holocaust is The Final Solution to the Jewish problem was a forced emigration program and not an extermination pogrom? borjastick: Removal or expulsion was the programme and the delivery method of the so called 'final solution Hekto...

borjastick: Stop avoiding the main claim that you have made and start trying to prove the points you think you know about. This isn't third grade playtime here, we are all equipped with X-Ray specs and bags of experience at this train stop mate and can sniff out half wits and fools from a mile off a...

Zolton: Lamptrecht, Is it plausible that the lengthy stops included time taken to let the Jews (and the train crews) out of the trains to go to the toilet, get some water and some food, give sick Jews some care or drop off Jews who were too sick to continue, in the hopes that taking a break at a ca...

Zolton: Nazgul, do you deny that the revisionist thesis is that the Nazis Final Solution to the Jewish problem was a forced emigration program and not an extermination pogram? Nazgul: I have no idea if there is a "revisionist thesis". That is off topic for this thread and will not be comme...

Zolton: Is it possible that Jews were not dying by the thousands, and the long stops were necessary to let the Jews off to get fresh air, go to the bathroom, get some water, cook some food, take care of the sick, etc? : Lamptrecht: It's possible they stopped for breaks of this nature, but it's also ...

Zolton: Is it possible that the lengthy stops included time taken to let the Jews (and the train crews) out of the trains to go to the toilet, get some water and some food, give sick Jews some care or drop off Jews who were too sick to continue, in the hopes that taking a break at a camp would help ...

Zolton: Is it possible that the lengthy stops included time taken to let the Jews (and the train crews) out of the trains to go to the toilet, get some water and some food, give sick Jews some care or drop off Jews who were too sick to continue, in the hopes that taking a break at a camp would help ...

I don't know where they went. I don't know where they are. Nobody knows. Do you? That's what I'm trying to figure out. Maybe you can help me out here. Correct me if I'm wrong. The revisionist thesis on the Holocaust is The Final Solution to the Jewish problem was a forced emigration program, not an...