So again: Give full disclosure of empirical evidence for the claims being made or shut up about it. That would be standard practice in any a-political homicide case (allegation or more that is, real or not). This is a thread about the revisionist narrative, and I was responding to the specific argu...

We do not know how the Hungarian Jews ended up in hundreds of different camps all across Europe, yet - evidently - there they were. How? We don't know. The same thing goes for the millions deported by Stalin to unknown destinations in "Siberia", the expulsions of ethnic Germans, etc. The ...

You are saying that the "better" testimonies say gasoline. Have you personally reviewed all of the potentially relevant testimony and confirmed that HC's testimony selection is honest? No, I'm not a capital R researcher on the level of HC blog people or Mattogno for that matter. I can onl...

One crucial difference between the Occupied Eastern Territories and Transnistria is that Transnistria was under Romanian control for most of the war, which naturally generated a torrent of correspondence between German and Romanian authorities pertaining to the treatment of both Romanian Jews and J...

⋅  Records deliberately destroyed by the Germans near the end of the war ⋅  Records maintained in the East kept secret, destroyed, or lost due to Soviet practices ⋅  Records lost in the chaos and destruction of the war, generally ⋅  Records not maintained due...

Again: If Rothfels wanted to say "on the spot" he'd have written something like "auf der Stelle" - as he did when quoting a Gerstein text. Moreover, it's Rothfels' commentary and not in the paragraph dedicated to Cornides disclosures. This is exactly what Rothfels wrote. You spe...

There are no records of any mass shipments of gasoline or other fuel to Belzec, bombsaway. There's no evidence of material shipments of any kind into the Reinhard camps (except for excavators for Treblinka I think) , all related vouchers were destroyed if we're to trust Globocnik's letter to Himmle...

I made a typo here (in bold) . I meant to say summations of events. Can you point out the most questionable/idiotic thing in Hilberg's first edition? Unlike Nuremberg or USSR summations of evidence, Hilberg drew on witness testimony and documentary evidence. His work is solid and I would expect erro...

If you go back and read the first edition of Hilberg or look at Nuremberg testimonies or read the reports of the Extraordinary State Commission and so forth, what you will find is that the whole thing is based on very questionable and frankly downright idiotic material. . Can you point out the most...

For the 434,508 Jews reportedly killed at Belzec, Mattogno notes that the amount of wood ash that would be produced in open-air cremation there would far exceed the total volume of Kola's pits (op cit). But even if we say just 100,000 Jews were killed there (which would invalidate many important &q...

1959. But the claim is it was written on the spot, so August/Sept 1942 Precisely. So what the "Cornides report" (or was it a diary?) boils down to is a book written by a third party more than 15 years after the fact, claiming (without evidence?) that a person by the name of Wilhelm Cornid...

How far? How does a train carriage behave differently when full or empty? I can see trains all day long full, half empty and empty and they don't look any different. Cornides says there were windows so you could see inside. I suppose the distance would depend on how good your vision was, though whe...

(bold mine) I don't understand this. Clearly burning stacked bodies would save some amount of fuel (how much I couldn't say). The area around a fire and especially above it also gets hot, am I crazy here? That clearly depends. Normally, you would encounter thermal inadequacy during water evaporatio...

You should try asking it about fuel requirements for cremating bodies, even without including any context about the Holocaust or the like. Simply ask for how easy/difficult it is to cremate a body outdoors and how much fuel it would take to cremate a body as well as many bodies simultaneously outdo...

bombsaway did all the inbound prisoners arrive in train transports? If yes what sort of transports were they? Cattle car type arrangements as was usual? If so when the trains left how would some local peasants working in the fields or in the town up the road know if they were empty or full? Cornide...