The Cornides report predates the widespread news of killing at the Reinhard camps which only began to widely circulate towards the end of 42. As for using "unsubstantiated hearsay" we can for comparison purposes examine some of the revisionist witness evidence for resettlement as shown in ...

It's more likely this came from long-term camp inmates trying to scare the newbies. Is that your explanation for this as well? A Sudeten-German foreman who was sitting at the same table commented: “Recently there was a drunk SS man sitting in our canteen, crying like a child. He said he was on duty...

The source is the Cornides report, which is what we were discussing. I was confused because it was worded differently in the link you posted. Regardless, this is all hearsay. The writer of the diary isn't a "witness" to anything that happened. He is just saying that other people said stuf...

If we accept Cornides' account as factual, the question is is the smoke a result of property being destroyed or human bodies? No witness testimony supports the former, but it does the latter The point is the claim is most consistent with property. If you want to say bodies, then that works just fin...

Yours was a long post so I'll just respond to the first couple of points to keep things manageable: The amount of human remains do not remotely account for claims of the "Holocaust". Out of 236 samples, only six were "positive" for human remains. Among these (TORC, p. 206-7): ......

Where did I change the story? Where did I say Reder was a star witness? If your claim is that gasoline engines were used in Belzec, Reder might just be your only witness. According to this there are others http://holocaustcontroversies.blogspot.com/2011/12/belzec-sobibor-treblinka-holocaust_9432.ht...

Rawa-Ruska is located to the east of the Reinhard camps. If they were slated for extermination, it makes no sense for them to have been deported to a locality east of the Reinhard camps, only for them to later be deported a short distance west to be gassed. Your argument here (they went through the...

It may be inferred from Roser's testimony that the Jews in the "kind of immense ghetto" in Rawa-Ruska must have, at least in part, been processed through the Reinhard camps, because the Jews deported straight to the occupied eastern territories (without going through a transit camp) are f...

Your method seems to be to try to imagine some scenario wherein your established beliefs might still remain intact. I do not think anyone looking at this objectively would do this sort of mental gymnastics. Changing the story, downplaying your own star witnesses (who are ultimately the basis for al...

Take a look at the map I posted. Kola took 2,227 samples, spaced 5m apart. Of these, he reported human remains in only 236 of the samples. This is approximately 10%. In other words, no remains in 90% of the camp, and often not even any ground disturbance. It is from these positive samples that he c...

Your excerpt/summary of Kola's 'study' as shown is misleading. What are his estimates for the number of bodies contained in each grave, and how does he justify it? As I recall, Mattogno (in "Belzec") focuses on this specifically and concludes an estimate of low thousands (perhaps even low...

What somebody said years after the fact is not robust evidence for a mass murder program, especially on the scale alleged. People can say anything. What does it matter if it's years later? Yes, people can say anything, at any time. That doesn't mean witness statements have no probative value. But t...

That's more common place than you think. But because they are commonly not believed, you won't hear a lot about this. But sometimes it is in the news: ....More recently, experts have discovered that some Vietnam-era veterans under psychiatric care in Veterans Administration Hospitals are especially...

Is it your claim that Jews were not deported west to the Reinhard camps, so any Jews that were brought east of these camps necessarily passed through them? No, none of those are my claims. The Reinhard camps served a bureaucratic and logistical purpose, and the main purpose of Project Reinhard was ...

y claim is not that Rawa-Ruska specifically was to become a Jewish settlement, or even a designated holding ground pending further settlement in Eastern Europe after the war. My claim is simply that Rawa-Ruska ended up becoming one of many regions in which Jews deported through the Reinhard camps e...