Jews "from all the countries of Europe", slated to be exterminated, being held in ghettos east of the Reinhard camps, is not in any way part of the orthodox narrative. Rawa-Ruska was incorporated into the General Government in 1941, so this doesn't even contradict Goebbels' very short com...

For example: a French POW deported to Ukraine during the war testified during the Nuremberg trials that "the Germans had turned the entire region of Lvov-Rawa-Ruska into a kind of immense ghetto" where "Jews from every nation in Europe" were settled. Here's the quote from the Nu...

The woman's tortured argument that the transcripts are accurate exists only because admitting otherwise means it's over: her book is transparently unreliable speculation, she can't even touch Hannah Arendt's argument that Eichmann was just a bureaucrat with a fusion role. Wilbur, I think questions ...

I think you're confused because the council is named after Wiegand. But a council is formally a non-living entity, like a ghetto or a political organization, though comprised of people. E.g could the Supreme Court be killed? Well maybe but this is problematic language-wise in my view. If Rosenberg ...

Butterfangers was correct. The transcripts were not released in an edited book on the topic, and it's not for lack of funding. The complete transcripts are still unavailable to the general public, and they're edits anyway. The issue is not moot at all. You chose to cut the next paragraph of my post...

I meant to mention that this suggestion of yours, that Goebbels did not learn about the "Final Solution" until late March of 1942, is NOT the standard position on your side. This is your own pet theory. HistorySpeaks, for example, in his recent Substack post, says Hitler announced the &qu...

I think it makes sense for revisionists to question the contents of the Sassen materials, given the facts at hand don't easily support their narrative. However if this is the belief (the photos with text out of focus were taken on purpose to hide something) there's still investigation to be done. So...

A surface narrative + underlying motivations for lying Why or how would it be necessary for me to produce a "narrative" for why a liar has told lies? It is sufficient that (1) we know this person does lie about a particular topic, (2) we know motives other than telling the truth existed f...

meant to include this in my response, re mass graves: ⋅  Who was going to investigate alleged USSR/Soviet graves? The Soviets? The inventors of show trials? Lol. What about the Russians, who say they exist, yet don't even claim to have done excavations in many cases? ⋅  And on Ca...

I asked you here to present a general narrative of what happened https://forum.codoh.com/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=14859&start=270#p109408 A surface narrative + underlying motivations for lying Here's what I came up with re surface narrative Let me try running out a general surface narrative and y...

I don't think that you've ever made a strong case, though we can continue to talk about it. I understand you'd like to continue to talk about it. I also understand that your reason for this is likely to portray these topics we are "debating" on as though your position still retains credib...

I see. So, you think there should be more documents. Well, I think there should be more physical evidence. If "extermination" happened as alleged, it is 100% certain the physical evidence can be found and verified. If resettlement happened as alleged, it is less than 100% certain that the...

The Korherr Report is about preparations for the Final Solution, it doesn't say it already happened. The title of the report is "The Final Solution of the European Jewish Problem". Where does it mention anything about preparations? (yet, we have still made a strong case that he did, which...

I've read the Korherr report before and don't recall anything contradicting the Schlegelberger and Luther documents. If you think there is something there, then you need to provide it. I did a search for "Final Solution" on several webpages hosting the Korrher report and didn't find anyth...

I meant to say the Schlegelberger document was corroborated by the Luther memo, not Lammers. I got the names mixed up. But what I said still stands. And nowhere does the Kroherr report contradict those memos. If anyone thinks it does, then post what you think is the contradiction. Yes, the Final So...