Dr. Makow seems to have other axes to grind. Here are some quotes from a female fan letter, published after the Holocaust article quoted above: You expressed what my intuition has always told me--women are not equal to men in authority; therefore, there should be no competition between the two. …………...

A résumé: Hannover wrote: I suggest that Erdmann's statements about coercion are valid since there is no corroborative evidence for euthanasia gassings, you have to say it opposite!!! i suggest erdmanns statement about threats are invalid since there is no coroborabitive evidence for threats. on the...

Thanks for your answer. I stand corrected. The word “Gaskammer” was actually used one way or another by Germans at this time. :oops: Butz refers to the title of a German book from 1943 that used the affix “-gaskammer” (“F. Puntigam et. al., Blausäuregaskammern zur Fleckfieberabwehr, Berlin, 1943”) i...

I don't see how a few spelling errors demonstrates forgery unless these are mistakes typically made by non-native German speakers. That being said, the Vergasungskeller note is somewhat less than convincing as a smoking-gun. Why not Gaskammer? :) Sailor (or Butz? I can’t remember at the moment) has...

http://130.149.134.79/journal/kkwiet001.htm Concerned about the warnings of German signals and intelligence experts that the simple, hand set code used for German Police wireless telegraphic transmission could easily be broken by the enemy, Kurt Daluege instructed the SS and Police commanders on 13...

Italian Jew Levi, more reputable than Weisel, said that he was told this by an SS guard: "We have won; there may be suspicions, but there will be no certainties, because we'll destroy the evidence together with you." This did not happen, at least not comprehensively, as far as I know. Does anybody ...

The key word seems to be "liquidated". According to the quoted interpretations were the Berlin Jews liquidated before Himmler's counter-order(?) had time to arrive. The counter-order proves the liquidation. "But-did it happen"? It must have happened, since there was a counter-order! You cannot stop ...

Since widukind has supplied us with excellent postings on this thread maybe I can take on the translation as a "service in return"? As you can see, widukind’s summary does what it says! But make some allowances for incorrect juridical terms in English (ie, “detention reparation applications”) "In gr...

Very interesting quotes from Burg’s books posted by Widukind! Thank you! On the Third Reich Forum Holocaust&Warcrimes section, the Moderator there has posted some very interesting scannings from the affidavit of Hans Marsalek (”Affidavit taken from "Nazi Conspiracy and Aggression" vol. VI, pp. 790-7...

Thanks for the reply. It's possible that I have misunderstood the posting rules, but the title of the thread doesn't specify neither Walendy nor Delmer but the subject under discussion seems to be Manufacturing 'historical facts' . Either way, there was no intention to "attack" anybody. The parenthe...

The German historian Ernst Nolte writes the following in his book Streitpunkte: Heutige und künftige Kontroversen um den Nationalsozialismus. Propyläen Verlag ISBN 3 549 05234 0 (1993), side 313-14: Dieser Fälschungsvorwurf wird hauptsächlich auf die angebliche Existenz einer riesigen Fälscherzentra...

If you feel the document is a forgery, then say so & why; if not, then say so & why. If the alleged original document is nowhere to be found then say it. Too much sparring and not enough discussion. Stay true to the point of the thread. Remember, there are others reading this board. Thanks, Moderat...