Hannover asked He mentions Franz, but gives us no specifics about what he finds compelling about him. Well actually I find nothing compelling about him at all, simply he supports my thesis that either an Extermination camp existed at Treblinka II or as the scientific researches of Richard Krege foun...

Hektor asked Exactly which part of the Stroop Report mentions this? Actually "destroyed by transportation" would be an odd German expression as well. http://www.holocaust-history.org/works/stroop-report/jpg/strp075.jpg Von den 56 065 insgesamt erfassten Juden sind ca. 7000 im Zuge der Gros...

The soil at Trebinka is quite sandy and looks like it is well draining. So no mud. If you recall that 1.5 klicks along the road there is a sand quarry that was dug into the ground, it is at least 12 meters deep and is as dry as a bone. Still I have no doubt that 800 000 bodies werent cremated on ope...

The idea of Aktion Reinhart camps being transit camps is superficially attractive but suffers from a lack of evidence. - One may say this even more about the claim that it had been an "Extermination camp " Actually there is a lot of evidence that they were Extermination camps. Including d...

The idea of Aktion Reinhart camps being transit camps is superficially attractive but suffers from a lack of evidence. For Treblinka II, for example, the aerial photos before liberation show hardly any buildings or signs of camp there at all. The Exterminationist story says that all the traces had b...

1. Zyklon-B (a commercial pesticide which contains cyanide) most definitely stains. Here's the outside and inside of an Auschwitz/Birkenau delousing chamber where Zyklon-B was used. Cyanide (or Zyklon B a commercial preparation of Hydrogen Cyanide) doesn't always stain, but it will stain under cert...

Vincent Ferrer, for reasons of your own you may not wish to reveal this, which is totally your right, but I would be interested in the name of this Treblinka expert.

It is always the evidence that is presented rather than the lack of evidence per se that convinces me that the Treblinka narrative is a fraud. The Treblinka narrative revolves around numerous gigantic mass graves 10 meters deep and 50 metres long and 25 meters wide (Wiernik). The excavations shown i...

I especially like it how Jerzy Tomaszewski "owns the credits" for this photo. This suggests a degree of proprietorship highly unusual for a supposedly purloined image. Surely the German soldier ought to have the copyright. Co-incidently....or not, Jerzy Tomaszewski happens to have been a p...

As far as the provenance of the photo is clearly dates from the war period. This does not make it genuine rather a fairly typical example of war black propaganda. As far as it goes for myself I doubt there is anything about that photo that could be used to definitively prove it false. After all supp...

Andrew Mathis believes there were homicidal gas chambers in Europe to the about the same extent that the CIA believed they were WMDs in Iraq prior to the invasion.

ie, both are far too intelligent to actually believe the nonsense they propagate.

Richard, The images were removed from Scott's Holocaust discussion forum because it is the opinion of one of the moderators that they are not genuine but the result of being "photoshopped" Apparantly he can think of no other explanation to explain the scaffolding. I wonder who exactly is t...

The only other thing I would add is I tried to post some of these pictures over at Scott Smith's "Free Speech" forum. Sadly free speech has its limitations and they were immediately removed from the Holocaust discussion section (ie the pictures of the scaffolding on the Krema chimney) I fi...

The final word that would determine if Majdanek had such a crematorium would come from aerial photos. I have only available a fairly poor web jpg downloaded either from John Ball's site or USHMM. I am certain that if one went to the original negative a much better resolution could be obtained. Such ...

A quick update on the of the Majdanek crematorium fraud. The claim that the ovens had not yet been built proved to be pre-mature. I have been provided with another photo from the same source that shows them conclusively http://img161.imageshack.us/img161/1989/majd9if.jpg The yellow oval marks one si...