Heavy Updates from Castle Hill (2022)

[DissentingOpinions]

It's an inference based on information from CODOH. The donation page currently lists Mattogno's only upcoming Holocaust Handbooks volume as "The Real Auschwitz Chronicle", which is currently in the thickening process - because there are no other research endeavors, logic tells me that this is the end.

That doesn't really mean much. I've seen periods of time where there were no books claiming to be coming out, and then Mattogno put out more books by surprise. His Auschwitz Chronicle hasn't even come out yet. You expect him to advertise literally every book he will ever do before it comes out? That is quite silly. You are not basing his supposed "retirement" on anything credible.

There was an interview Germar Rudolf partook in with Jim Rizoli about the Holocaust Handbooks series a while back, and Germar himself stated he wanted to cap off the number of volumes around 50. We’ve always had news of upcoming volumes through the donation page or the Holocaust Handbooks website, which would often fall behind due to Michael Santomauro not keeping up with releases. What else could Mattogno write about? That unreleased title on the interrogations of the Topf engineers, or tracking the resettled Jews? Both seem unlikely, and without a website for Mattogno, it’s impossible to keep track of him.

[Merlin300]

I hope that Germar is doing well. It makes me feel terrible to know of his continual plight. He's done so much good for the world, and has sacrificed so much of his life. Given his efforts, and others like Sylvia Stolz, I'm often asking myself: what can I do to help? Does anyone have any thoughts on this? I've thought about starting a local revisionist group, or opening a small revisionist dedicated bookstore.

Sending an email to the Netherlands Central Government is an important start. (I saw you already did, Jarno)
There is a form website for intake questions- Hit the website and say, Please hear from Revisionist scholars before your criminalize their speech.

Do you have a question about the laws or regulations in the Netherlands? Use this form to ask your question by email.
https://www.government.nl/contact/publi ... formheader.

Here is the Questiion I submitted-


Letter sent
Dear Ministry of General Affairs,

My name is David Merlin. I am writing from the
United States and am a member of the
Committee for Open Debate on the Holocaust.
I would like to respectfully oppose the ban on "Holocaust Denial" being proposed by
Justice Minister Dilan Yeşilgöz-Zegerius.


I suspect the information the Honorable Justice Minister might have about "deniers" is incomplete. (The accurate term is Revisionist.)
I would like to present the view of a Revisionist organization and would like to know where to best direct my comments.

We feel that a law which would criminalize honest discussion and debate of historical topics is a serious mistake.

CODOH is an association of scholars and lawyers
open to all who are interested in history, honest research, and polite discussion.

Our founder Bradley Smith wrote ,
"Although it is standard practice to defame Revisionists as 'anti-Semites who claim the Holocaust is just Jewish propaganda,' that is not what we at CODOH argue. Briefly, we believe that much of that history that we are taught today has been influenced by Soviet, British and American wartime propaganda which exaggerated and exploited real tragedies for propaganda purposes. This concerns not just Jews but Slavs, Roma, Jehovah’s Witnesses and, in some versions, Gays. It can be argued that there is considerable research that supports this point of view."

Please let me know the best address to send
our comments. Thank you,

David Merlin
Member of CODOH

[curioussoul]

What else could Mattogno write about? That unreleased title on the interrogations of the Topf engineers, or tracking the resettled Jews?

Mattogno has already almost single-handedly disproven the holocaust story. But obviously the most important study would be to track the resettled jews in eastern europe. This would be a monumental task, because it would require archival access to rare archives which don't allow revisionists or even outside visitors.

Thomas Kues did his job with the available materials and pretty much proved his case in his 3-part series, but seeing a full-caliber book from Mattogno on this particular topic would be so interesting, especially given his vast collection of source materials and contacts within important institutions that can provide documents.

in this regard, i think Mattogno did a great job in The Making of the Auschwitz Myth (pages 76f - The Typhus Epidemic and the “Ostwanderung”).

[greatmystery]

I also have mild suspicions about the TRS crew and Peinovich in particular, but that is another issue. .

What are your mild suspicions?
Mike is my husband. TRS/NJP promotes White advocacy and they do not hide that fact. They also don't hide the fact that Jewish rule is harmful to White people. They honestly don't believe in the Holocaust and they think the continuation of it's false narrative is particularly harmful to White people and the Middle East. They are not feds, they are not gatekeepers. I know a lot of slander flies around about them, but that's because COINTELPRO type operations being waged by our enemies. T
Also, TRS has been promoting Castle Hill and COH+DOH books for year and I do the same on my website (holocaust.claims).

[fireofice]

I also have mild suspicions about the TRS crew and Peinovich in particular, but that is another issue. .

What are your mild suspicions?
Mike is my husband. TRS/NJP promotes White advocacy and they do not hide that fact. They also don't hide the fact that Jewish rule is harmful to White people. They honestly don't believe in the Holocaust and they think the continuation of it's false narrative is particularly harmful to White people and the Middle East. They are not feds, they are not gatekeepers. I know a lot of slander flies around about them, but that's because COINTELPRO type operations being waged by our enemies. T
Also, TRS has been promoting Castle Hill and COH+DOH books for year and I do the same on my website (holocaust.claims).

I have no suspicions towards TRS or Mike. I've utilized some of their podcasts on the holocaust on this forum as have others. They have been very helpful in my understanding of the holocaust. Some people are just overly paranoid, I guess.

[Butterfangers]

I also have mild suspicions about the TRS crew and Peinovich in particular, but that is another issue. .

What are your mild suspicions?
Mike is my husband. TRS/NJP promotes White advocacy and they do not hide that fact. They also don't hide the fact that Jewish rule is harmful to White people. They honestly don't believe in the Holocaust and they think the continuation of it's false narrative is particularly harmful to White people and the Middle East. They are not feds, they are not gatekeepers. I know a lot of slander flies around about them, but that's because COINTELPRO type operations being waged by our enemies. T
Also, TRS has been promoting Castle Hill and COH+DOH books for year and I do the same on my website (holocaust.claims).

Some of my concerns are summarized here, and I think they're well-founded: https://christogenea.org/podcasts/wrong ... de-edition

Some others, here: https://media.christogenea.org/tags/mikeenoch

Beyond that, some of the TRS "takes" on Covid vaccine-bioweapons are especially concerning, given the impact on European fertility and the fact that the type of global war now occurring is demographic in nature, and fertility is right where Europeans are most vulnerable. I'd rather not veer too far off-topic on this thread but feel free to PM if you'd care to discuss further.

I think you do good work from what I have seen on holocaust.claims and there are a lot of things I've appreciated about Mike and TRS but my view is that when you have a large following, it's many-fold more suspicious (or at least highly concerning) when you tacitly enable key initiatives which work against the overall effort you claim to represent. The Covid vaccine enabling was the last straw for me, personally. It's just my opinion.

[greatmystery]

I also have mild suspicions about the TRS crew and Peinovich in particular, but that is another issue. .

What are your mild suspicions?
Mike is my husband. TRS/NJP promotes White advocacy and they do not hide that fact. They also don't hide the fact that Jewish rule is harmful to White people. They honestly don't believe in the Holocaust and they think the continuation of it's false narrative is particularly harmful to White people and the Middle East. They are not feds, they are not gatekeepers. I know a lot of slander flies around about them, but that's because COINTELPRO type operations being waged by our enemies. T
Also, TRS has been promoting Castle Hill and COH+DOH books for year and I do the same on my website (holocaust.claims).

Some of my concerns are summarized here, and I think they're well-founded: https://christogenea.org/podcasts/wrong ... de-edition

Some others, here: https://media.christogenea.org/tags/mikeenoch

Beyond that, some of the TRS "takes" on Covid vaccine-bioweapons are especially concerning, given the impact on European fertility and the fact that the type of global war now occurring is demographic in nature, and fertility is right where Europeans are most vulnerable. I'd rather not veer too far off-topic on this thread but feel free to PM if you'd care to discuss further.

I think you do good work from what I have seen on holocaust.claims and there are a lot of things I've appreciated about Mike and TRS but my view is that when you have a large following, it's many-fold more suspicious (or at least highly concerning) when you tacitly enable key initiatives which work against the overall effort you claim to represent. The Covid vaccine enabling was the last straw for me, personally. It's just my opinion.

Mike was once married to a half Jew before his political views matured. So what? I imagine that website has it out for Mike because he thinks the Christian identity thing is stupid. The claims in that article aren't worth addressing although I will say Mike is not Jewish and Ames was not a member of B'nai B'rith.

TRS and NJP have never been vax shills, although our enemies like to make it seem that way. Also, Mike has not seen any convincing evidence that the vax has affected European fertility, but that doesn't make him a vax enabler.

TRS and NJP are pro White groups that cause problems for the Jewish elite. They have all sorts of gay ops working against them all the time. I think it's more important to look at their actions and what they accomplish rather than listen to haters and bad actors.

To keep things on topic here is a video of TRS's interview with Germar Rudolf. I hope that guy is doing ok.
https://therightstuff.biz/?s=rudolf&doi ... 7246093750

[Hektor]

....

Mike was once married to a half Jew before his political views matured. So what? I imagine that website has it out for Mike because he thinks the Christian identity thing is stupid. The claims in that article aren't worth addressing although I will say Mike is not Jewish and Ames was not a member of B'nai B'rith.

TRS and NJP have never been vax shills, although our enemies like to make it seem that way. Also, Mike has not seen any convincing evidence that the vax has affected European fertility, but that doesn't make him a vax enabler.

TRS and NJP are pro White groups that cause problems for the Jewish elite. They have all sorts of gay ops working against them all the time. I think it's more important to look at their actions and what they accomplish rather than listen to haters and bad actors.

To keep things on topic here is a video of TRS's interview with Germar Rudolf. I hope that guy is doing ok.
https://therightstuff.biz/?s=rudolf&doi ... 7246093750

You can't answer to all the issues all of the time. And when you have limited resources those need to be spend completely on the issue you try addressing with your publishing. Otherwise you muddy the waters and clog the spear.

I think I made it clear in the past:
* I think the whole COVID thing was a scam right from the beginning. No proof of virus (SARSCOV), lots of fearmongering, lots of fallacious arguing that there must be 'a virus somewhere'. People seriously believed that when you can point at sick people or hospital mismanagement effects that this somehow proves that there is a virus. Also no proof of necessity for any of the measure. In fact they were obviously counterproductive in many ways. Good indication that lockdown-effects and mass-psychogenic illness did make people sick (with physical symptoms). Also indication that international banks pressurized/bribed governments to implement lockdowns.
* I'm not a fan of vaccinations and even less of prescribing people what treatments they should undergo. There is no really good study on the long term effects of vaccinating. And the argument that "without vaccines we would be all dead" is flawed. What they do is compare mortality figures before vaccination campaigns with those after one. In the process ignoring ALL the other figures. E.g. anything related to living conditions.
* Concerning debates and arguments. I don't give a damn what somebodies family background is. Most people don't know who the great grandparents of their spouses are neither. So why the obsession to investigate this and making it a debating point? There should be other means to assess how trustworthy somebody is. (Sure there is other reasons to consider ancestry, but this is besides the point).
* "Christian Identity" has a similar ring to it as do variants of Judaism have. Some of it is even a mirror image of it. Their arguments are partially quite similar to Jewish Mysticism, which calls into question where this is actually coming from. Personally I view it as a reaction towards the Liberalism of the mainline Churches and their Humanism, Universalism and other adoption of worldly ideologies over the past decades. The later wasn't the common Christian View prior to World War Two btw. with the exception of perhaps some then rather obnoxious theologians. The Protestants, Catholics, Orthodox and most of the other denominations DID embrace Nationhood, family and social conservatives view. They were not as concerned about form of government neither. And quite correctly considered Humanism, Marxism anti-Christian. The Catholics were perhaps the most universalist (as their name implies), but even they viewed race, nation, tribe as 'having a place' in people's world views. But universalism already fails simple tests of compliance with biblical doctrine. It says there 'love thy neighbor' instead of love everybody or love 'all people of the world' or something. There is other issues as well, but I think that a lot of Christians have lost common sense over the year simply following the commands, teachings and statements they think the big shots in their church do believe. One principle is that those that are carnally are simply in error on anything. Not always to the same degree of course... But it is something that needs to be considered.
* Anyway, how does it all link to Holocaust Revisionism. I think the subject is already a piece of work in itself. And if you add cross-sectional issues... You'd already have enough work for a whole university of scholars and researchers there. Meanwhile the question whether the Holocaust is a valid historical event can actually be answered pretty quickly. If it was, there would be plenty of hard evidence for it. But there isn't. So those pushing the narrative have to use all kinds of innuendo and mind games to make people believe in it.

With Mike Peinovich. The guy has some of his own interest as well. Since he got a party. So it isn't exactly a secret. But at least he has noticed that there is something seriously wrong with Holocaust narrative and isn't scared to say this publicly. That makes him better than the bulk of professional historians. Who either choose to affirm the issue or be silent on it, using their ignorance as an excuse ('It's not in my field of study').


The infighting and quarrelling is typical for fringe groups that don't have lots of leverage and lack resources to keep people busy. That is now except for the characters that can never stop to find fault with other people and feel they are not given the position, attention and praise they deserve. Those can be really a pain in the ass, if you want a group that works for defined goals. It is however also an issue that can be managed.