Is "Red Symphony" Legit?

[JohnDoe1964]

I didn't find out the Rosenthal Interview was fake until after I read it, so I want to find out if the Red Symphony Interview is fake too before I read it.

Can anyone help me out here? In particular I'd like Hannover's opinion on this since I find him the best Holocaust Hoax investigator on the net.

[Hannover]

I didn't find out the Rosenthal Interview was fake until after I read it, so I want to find out if the Red Symphony Interview is fake too before I read it.

Can anyone help me out here? In particular I'd like Hannover's opinion on this since I find him the best Holocaust Hoax investigator on the net.

First of all, thank you for your compliment.

As for the 'Red Symphony', indeed I have heard of this book, but frankly haven't really delved deeply into it.
http://www.amazon.com/Red-Symphony-J-La ... 1939438314

Amazon quote:

Dr. Landowsky was a Russianized Pole and lived in Russia. His father, a Colonel of the Russian Imperial Army, was shot by the Bolsheviks during the 1917 revolution. The life-story of Dr. Landowsky is astonishing. He finished the Faculty of Medicine in Russia before the revolution and then studied two years at the Sorbonne in Paris, and he spoke fluent French. He was interested in the effects of drugs on the human organism, to help surgeons in operations. Being a talented doctor, he carried out experiments in this field and had achieved considerable results. The all-seeing NKVD (secret police) became interested in these works and easily discovered the real author. His specialty was very valuable for them. One day in 1936 there was a knock at the doctor's door. He was invited to follow, and he was never again allowed to rejoin his family. He was placed in the building of the chemical laboratory of the NKVD near Moscow. He lived there and was forced to carry out various jobs given to him by his masters, he was a witness at questionings, tortures and the most terrible happenings and crimes. This book is an exact recorded report of the questioning of the former Ambassador in France, C.G. Rakovsky during the period of the trials of the Trotskyists in the USSR in 1938, when he was tried together with Bukharin, Rykoff, Yagoda, Karakhan, Dr. Levin and others. The questioning took place in French by this agent. The doctor was present in order to put drug pills unnoticed into the glass of Rakovsky, to induce energy and a good mood. Behind the wall the conversation was registered on apparatus, and the technician who operated it did not understand French. Then Dr. Landowsky had to translate into Russian, with two copies, for Stalin and Gabriel. Secretly he dared to make a carbon copy, which he hid anyway.

Each of these claims, which given the demonstrated insanity and utter barbarity of the Stalin regime seem plausible, would require further confirmation on a case by case basis. I'm curious how well sourced the book is.
The notion that the Trotskyist trials were somehow recorded and subsequently made public seems far fetched.
Perhaps a trip to Russian archives might be helpful, if the files are not off limits.

There are the claims within this book that Jews financed Hitler for their own interests which involved odd stories of them meeting with Hitler, etc. All that seems like a stretch, IMO. Of course the fact that the National Socialists received support from German and other European industrialists who then profited seems reasonable to me. Nothing sinister about it though.
Hitler's alleged financing has popped up in many stories, i.e.: Hitler was supposedly financed by IBM, by the Bush family, by Henry Ford, on & on.
Of course foreign investors would have wanted to invest in Germany, they made / make great products, offer / offered services in which investors did & do make money. Nothing peculiar about it. As I like to say, 'there are the Nazis with the 6M & gas chambers and there are the Nazis without the 6M & gas chambers'.

As for the:

Harold Wallace Rosenthal Interview

"At a very early date, urged on by the desire to make our way in the world, Jews began to look for a means whereby we might distract all attention from the racial aspect. What could be more effective, and at the same time more above suspicion, than to borrow and utilize the idea of a religious community? We've been forced to borrow this idea from the Aryans. We jews never possessed any religious institution which developed out of our own consciousness, for we lack any kind of idealism. This means that a belief in life beyond this terrestrial existence is foreign to us. As a matter of fact, the Talmud does not lay down principles with which to prepare the individual for a life to come, but furnishes only rules for a sumptuous life in this world. It is a collection of instructions for maintaining the Jewish race and regulating: intercourses between us and the goy. Our teachings; are not concerned with moral problems, but rather with how to 'get.' (This explains the parasitic nature of Jewish people. Jews never get rich off one another, but seek to 'get' the labor and wealth of others.)

Generally, this reminds me of 'The Protocols of the Elders of Zion' which is claimed to be a forgery, yet the world Zionist situation & behavior would seem to validate it's contents.

Regards, Hannover

[JohnDoe1964]

Thanks for response. I agree that the claim of Hitler doing dealings with a Jew (Mr. Paul Warburg, specifically) without knowing it was a Jew, is not credible. Especially since the Jew, Dr. Henry Makow, pushes this idea while simultaneously pushing the Holocaust story.

I would also agree that the treatment given to the Red Symphony interview by Jews lends credibility to it, however the fact that the interviewee quotes a paragraph from Mein Kamf almost verbatim kind of ruins it for me.

Thanks very much for your time.

[Hannover]

JohnDoe1964, I found this.
http://www.codoh.com/library/document/108/

- Hannover

The Pro-Red Orchestra Starts Tuning Up in the U.S.A., 1941
By James Joseph Martin

Table of Contents

Opinions and Opinion Makers in the U.S.A.
Winston Churchill as a Factor Influencing Americans at the Outset, June 1941
Initial Reaction of Interventionist Spokesmen and Press to the Soviet Entry into the European War
Some Diplomatic and Economic Straws in the Wind
The Roosevelt Administration and Press Supporters Lean Toward Aid at the Time of the August 1941 Atlantic Conference
The Main Pockets of Resistance to Supporting Stalin
American Communists as a Complication in the Soviet Aid Debate
Time, Corporate America and "Culture" Contribute to the Confusion
New Voices in Behalf of Assistance to Stalin, at Home and Abroad
Continued Annoyance from Influential Anti-Soviet Liberal Personalities, While Pro-Aid Forces Gain in Academe
October, 1941 Polls Register a Gain in Aid-to-Stalin Sentiment
President Roosevelt Creates a Diversion Over the Religious Issue
Diplomatic Moves Toward Vastly Increased Military Aid to Stalin
Culture, Big Names and the Well-Placed Lend Their Assistance to the Building Pro-Soviet Bandwagon
Echoes of the Religious Dust Up Reverberate
British Propaganda Diversions, and Related American Anglophile Support for the Growing Enhancement of Stalin
Fellow Travelers Domestic and Foreign Add Their Bit
Vote of No Confidence from the Saturday Evening Post/Some Practical Consequences of Soviet Aid Get Aired
The Origins of "Second Front" Talk in the West, and the Impact of Soviet Aid Production on American Labor and Business/ Businessmen
Pearl Harbor Forces a Temporary Diversion in the Overall Drive to Assist the Soviet Union
Reactions and Second-Guessing Following Stalin's Avoidance of Involvement in the War Against Japan
The Dimensions of the Propaganda War as Waged by the Authors and Publishers
The Ante Rises After Pearl Harbor on Production and Appropriations for Stalin/Davies' Book Mission to Moscow Sets the Tone on the Adulation of Soviet Communism for the Rest of the War
Notes, 1-25
Notes, 26-100
Notes, 101-211