When Victims Rule

[Ed Toner]

http://www.jewishtribalreview.org/01intro.htm

This is a discussion site that raises a lot of questions, provides many answers, and
should have you thinking about a taboo subject, that shouldn't be.

[Hebden]

http://www.jewishtribalreview.org/01intro.htm

This is a discussion site that raises a lot of questions, provides many answers, and should have you thinking about a taboo subject, that shouldn't be.

We contend that the above post falls outside the purview of this BBS and should, accordingly, be deleted forthwith.

We suggest Mr. Toner may wish to take out a subscription to the Journal of Historical Review.

[Braveheart]

http://www.jewishtribalreview.org/01intro.htm

This is a discussion site that raises a lot of questions, provides many answers, and should have you thinking about a taboo subject, that shouldn't be.

We contend that the above post falls outside the purview of this BBS and should, accordingly, be deleted forthwith.

We suggest Mr. Toner may wish to take out a subscription to the Journal of Historical Review.

Do you normally refer to yourself in the first-person plural?

The site contains many quotes by Jewish individuals that fall neatly within the folds of historical revisionism, and it should be allowed to stand.

One of the quotes is:

"By accusing western democracies of anti-Semitism, the Jews put them on the defensive. As long as guilt feelings can be profitably mined, advantages can be gained. But the lode is not likely to last forever."

-- Moshe Leshem

Surely one who has publicly criticized the Holocaust story is familiar with the "anti-semite" smear, as are those who presently lambast the state of Israel, for which the Holocaust serves as the raison d'etre.

"We" suggest that this board lighten up with its myriad of guidelines and policies. Different posters have different ways of contributing and stimulating discussion.

[Scott]

http://www.jewishtribalreview.org/01intro.htm

This is a discussion site that raises a lot of questions, provides many answers, and should have you thinking about a taboo subject, that shouldn't be.

We contend that the above post falls outside the purview of this BBS and should, accordingly, be deleted forthwith.

We suggest Mr. Toner may wish to take out a subscription to the Journal of Historical Review.

Discussion, however, may not be outside the purview of this site:

[Moderator]

OK, it will stand; but if the thread grows without 'holocaust' connections being made it will be pulled.

Carry on.

Moderator

[Hebden]

OK, it will stand; but if the thread grows without 'holocaust' connections being made it will be pulled.

Carry on.

Moderator

There would not have been a problem if Mr. Toner had specificaly linked to the chapters devoted to the Holocaust:

http://www.jewishtribalreview.org/18holo1.htm

http://www.jewishtribalreview.org/18holo2.htm

The site is, if nothing else, a source of many interesting quotes:

"Every time I attend a gathering of Jewish children," wrote well-known lawyer Alan Dershowitz in 1991, "at a family event, at a Bar Mitzvah, at Simchath Torah -- I imagine SS guards lining up these children for the gas chambers." [DERSHOWITZ, p. 178]

[Ed Toner]

I invite your attention to Chapter 18, in 2 parts, which deals with the holocaust in great detail, much of which has not been previously discussed on this subject.

[Hannover]

What about those chapters specifically? Please give us your comments.

- H.