Germar Rudolf's Responses to Richard Green

[Otium]

I wanted to link here Germar's responses to Richard Green simply for the sake of easy references.

---

Germar has responded, and/or commented on Richard Green in the following books and articles:

In the updated 2019 edition of the edited volume 'Dissecting the Holocaust: The Growing Critique of “Truth” and “Memory.”' Germar's chapter entitled: 'The Technique and Chemistry of the ‘Gas Chambers’ of Auschwitz', pgs. 331-365.
Link | Archive - PDF | Archive

In the updated 2020 edition of Germar's book 'The Chemistry of Auschwitz' in Chapter 8, subchapter 8.4.4. pgs. 347-353.
Link | Archive - PDF | Archive

In the updated 2017 edition of the book 'Auschwitz Lies: Legends, Lies and Prejudices on the Holocaust', Germar's chapter entitled: 'Green sees Red', pgs, 71-88.
Link | Archive - PDF | Archive

August 9, 1998 - 'Some considerations about the ›Gas Chambers‹ of Auschwitz and Birkenau'
Link | Archive 1 | Archive 2

August 30, 1999 - 'Character Assasinations'
Link | Archive 1 | Archive 2

October 8, 2003 - 'Dr. Richard Green's Evasions'
Link | Archive 1 | Archive 2

See too this relevant article from 2013 published by the Inconvenient History Journal by Germar Rudolf and Nicholas Kollerstrom, entitled: 'Differential Exposure of Brickwork to Hydrogen Cyanide during World War Two'
Link 1 | Link 2 - Archive 1 - 1 | Archive 1 - 2 | Archive 2 - 1 | Archive 2 - 2

---

Germar may have also referred to Green on his website previously at: http://germarrudolf.com/, so if I'm forgetting anything please let me know.

[Hektor]

Richard Green essentially tries to make lots of words to cover up that they don't have anything worth showing in terms of forensic evidence supporting the extermination thesis. The issue is that he isn't open for arguments at all. Green sticks to the Holocaust claims and cites 'testimony'.... The testimony has problems and isn't backed up at all by forensic evidence. If he can't acknowledge that clearly, he got a problem and isn't interested in the truth at all.

[Fred zz]

from whom does this "They washed the room after each gassing" come from?

[Lamprecht]

from whom does this "They washed the room after each gassing" come from?

Here's a thread on the subject;

Those Prussian Blues Just Won't Wash
viewtopic.php?t=4600

[borjastick]

Yeah, those pesky practicalities and evidence or lack thereof keep getting in the way. Ooops!

Sending millions of jews all the way across europe just to kill them. Ooops.

Cremating all those dead jews inside 15 minutes. Ooops.

Loading the single hand-drawn elevator against the clock to be able to cremate all those jews inside 15 minutes. Ooops.

Having to keep those poor jews waiting outside in the cold while the gas chamber is washed and painted every single time. Ooops.

Shooting and burying them there jews in mass graves right across eastern europe and then forgetting where they are. Ooops.

Not having any trace of all those dead jews, not even millions of their teeth, after having got rid of them at Auschwitz. Ooops.

I could go on but I'm expecting a DHL delivery and life goes on. Ooops.

[Hektor]

Yeah, those pesky practicalities and evidence or lack thereof keep getting in the way. Ooops!

Sending millions of jews all the way across europe just to kill them. Ooops.

Cremating all those dead jews inside 15 minutes. Ooops.

Loading the single hand-drawn elevator against the clock to be able to cremate all those jews inside 15 minutes. Ooops.

Having to keep those poor jews waiting outside in the cold while the gas chamber is washed and painted every single time. Ooops.

Shooting and burying them there jews in mass graves right across eastern europe and then forgetting where they are. Ooops.

Not having any trace of all those dead jews, not even millions of their teeth, after having got rid of them at Auschwitz. Ooops.

I could go on but I'm expecting a DHL delivery and life goes on. Ooops.

The narrative is riddled with obnoxious claims. Still people are forced to believe it.

Germar Rudolf tried to test, whether key claims being made can be verified... He demonstrated they couldn't.
But Green insists that we still must believe them. Because he and his buddies say so.
He actually doesn't claim that it is physically proven, just tries to find excuses why it couldn't.

It's mostly about prussian blue and why that not forming doesn't demonstrate that the place wasn't used as alleged. Green ignores the other problems with the narrative, but I guess he simply will claim that 'he isn't an expert on this'. How is now 'expert enough' to assert the Holocaust claims is beyond me.

[Fred zz]

from whom does this "They washed the room after each gassing" come from?

Here's a thread on the subject;

Those Prussian Blues Just Won't Wash
viewtopic.php?t=4600

Thanks for the response.
I have some basic and/or simplistic thoughts on this issue but do hear me out.
For the moment let's consider the room is full of naked people standing shoulder to shoulder and the Zyklon comes down, and now there is a big panic inside the room. .
Now think in terms of how the human body releaves him or herself by peeing or pooing.
I will assume we all understand human anatomy. If one is standing in a crowded gas chamber and discharges out of panic and/or fear, the orifices that human waste discharges from both are pointed downward, Yes, the floor would have to be cleaned, and perhaps the wall no more than 3 feet (915mm) would be cleaned up, However from the cleaning crew's standpoint, mid wall height and especially upper wall height and ceiling would not require cleaning and be skipped because there is nothing to clean. No human has the muscle to pee to the upper wall or ceiling, and I would add no one would be thinking of their pee pee while being gassed and panicked, so we can assume it would be pointed downward.

The only blood discharge I can think of is someone getting hit in the nose in a panic. People have been hit by cars and do not bleed externally. Internally perhaps. Regardless in all 3 cases, gravity is not working in favor of the people who believe this nonsense.
I attached a photo to give reference of how high the ceiling is. Note the height of the man with red top. I give no pee stains higher than his waist.
am I missing anything here?

[borjastick]

Now think in terms of how the human body releaves him or herself by peeing or pooing.

am I missing anything here?

Yes you are. You are buying into the claim and assumption that some/many/all people inside a gas chamber (that has never been shown to exist or operate btw) will defecate themselves during the process of falling to the ground while falling asleep or however ZyklonB would afflict people. The claim of walls covered in poo assumes also that everyone was close to the wall and could projectile poo at some speed.

It also assumes the gas chambers were real, in operation and did their job.

I assume none of this happened.

[Fred zz]

I am not selling the gas chamber theory. I am stating merely stating what would happen if the room was full of people in a big panic.
Never said anything about poo on the wall. I clearly stated gravity is not working in the favor who believe in the hoax as things fall downward

[Horhug]

I wanted to link here Germar's responses to Richard Green simply for the sake of easy references.

---

Germar has responded, and/or commented on Richard Green in the following books and articles:

In the updated 2019 edition of the edited volume 'Dissecting the Holocaust: The Growing Critique of “Truth” and “Memory.”' Germar's chapter entitled: 'The Technique and Chemistry of the ‘Gas Chambers’ of Auschwitz', pgs. 331-365.
Link | Archive - PDF | Archive

In the updated 2020 edition of Germar's book 'The Chemistry of Auschwitz' in Chapter 8, subchapter 8.4.4. pgs. 347-353.
Link | Archive - PDF | Archive

In the updated 2017 edition of the book 'Auschwitz Lies: Legends, Lies and Prejudices on the Holocaust', Germar's chapter entitled: 'Green sees Red', pgs, 71-88.
Link | Archive - PDF | Archive

August 9, 1998 - 'Some considerations about the ›Gas Chambers‹ of Auschwitz and Birkenau'
Link | Archive 1 | Archive 2

August 30, 1999 - 'Character Assasinations'
Link | Archive 1 | Archive 2

October 8, 2003 - 'Dr. Richard Green's Evasions'
Link | Archive 1 | Archive 2

See too this relevant article from 2013 published by the Inconvenient History Journal by Germar Rudolf and Nicholas Kollerstrom, entitled: 'Differential Exposure of Brickwork to Hydrogen Cyanide during World War Two'
Link 1 | Link 2 - Archive 1 - 1 | Archive 1 - 2 | Archive 2 - 1 | Archive 2 - 2

---

Germar may have also referred to Green on his website previously at: http://germarrudolf.com/, so if I'm forgetting anything please let me know.

See also :

Holocaust Handbooks, Volume 18:
Germar Rudolf, Carlo Mattogno: Auschwitz Lies—Legends, Lies, and Prejudices on the Holocaust
4th, revised and expanded edition of 2017.
https://holocausthandbooks.com/index.php?page_id=18



.

[Otium]

See also :

Holocaust Handbooks, Volume 18:
Germar Rudolf, Carlo Mattogno: Auschwitz Lies—Legends, Lies, and Prejudices on the Holocaust
4th, revised and expanded edition of 2017.
https://holocausthandbooks.com/index.php?page_id=18

You will see I have already linked that.

[Otium]

So you did. Sorry I missed it.

Are you aware of :

- Germar's articles on Green's responses at GR's VHO site?

- Pages at the old Nikzor site?

- Green's articles at holocaust-history.org?

[Otium]

So you did. Sorry I missed it.

Are you aware of :

- Germar's articles on Green's responses at GR's VHO site?

- Pages at the old Nikzor site?

- Green's articles at holocaust-history.org?

I have linked the VHO articles.

The point wasn't to bother linking any of the Nizkor/Green articles. The point was to collect Germar's responses.