Fred thanks for the reply. I was surprised to see Mattogno cite Wikipedia. But the two other citations he provides point to an important history regarding this claim which is written off as being based on confusion. I find it impossible to believe that this was pure rumor that materialised organically among detainees at the camp, which is what they seem to want to suggest indirectly. I believe that establishing this narative is important to them because the actual source of 'gas through shower heads' would be far too inconvenient for obviously reasons.
Do we have anything of substance to support the museum at Majdanek claiming that gas came through the shower heads?
My Majdanek Presentation almost completed / now completed
Moderator: Moderator
Forum rules
Be sure to read the Rules/guidelines before you post!
Be sure to read the Rules/guidelines before you post!
Re: My Majdanek Presentation almost completed / now completed
I don't recall if Eric Hunt pointed out the water valves. Seeing this, for what i think is the first time in Fred's report ... gas through shower heads with valves IN the shower room!
Re: My Majdanek Presentation almost completed / now completed
Since the 1960s, the museum has not claimed this room to be a gas chamber. So the 6 windows and the mechanics of getting gas through pipes that had water in them presents itself as common sense thinking even for the historians
I do recalled Mr. Hunt saying in his video "Its a real shower"
I do recalled Mr. Hunt saying in his video "Its a real shower"
History is never a one-sided story.
Re: My Majdanek Presentation almost completed / now completed
Fred zz wrote:Since the 1960s, the museum has not claimed this room to be a gas chamber. So the 6 windows and the mechanics of getting gas through pipes that had water in them presents itself as common sense thinking even for the historians
I do recalled Mr. Hunt saying in his video "Its a real shower"
They'll drop stories, when they falsehood is too obvious to the audience, or at least potentially so.
Even believer Historians will realize that they ice they are actually standing on is quite thin. And well, if the narrative collapses, they can look for another career as well.
Re: My Majdanek Presentation almost completed / now completed
See attachment of the long version about the ovens in the new crematoria at Majdanek
I posted the whole article and three blowups of the contents of the whole article I wish to point out
Katyn attachment
As you read this, ponder who exactly was responsible for Katyn event. Out and out BS
Read 1a then 1b in order
States they were able to cremate 6 bodies at one time. Interesting BS here.
See 1c and 1d
In Japan I have been to two cremations, You say your last Good byes, the body is put in the oven, the participants wait in a waiting room, and 45 minutes later they come and get you to watch the body being taken out
Now
Look 1c. How were they able to get those bodies laid out so well on the ground in front of the ovens?, Seems fishy. All I saw in Japan were smaller pieces.
Look at 1d. I feel the oven would not operate properly with that pile of remains. Hot gas comes from the bottom. It seems the remains were shoveled in there? Things that make you go hmmm. If it looks like that inside the oven (1d) shoveled in there, how did they get the remains out and on the ground in front of the ovens so neatly as indicated in photo 1c?
I posted the whole article and three blowups of the contents of the whole article I wish to point out
Katyn attachment
As you read this, ponder who exactly was responsible for Katyn event. Out and out BS
Read 1a then 1b in order
States they were able to cremate 6 bodies at one time. Interesting BS here.
See 1c and 1d
In Japan I have been to two cremations, You say your last Good byes, the body is put in the oven, the participants wait in a waiting room, and 45 minutes later they come and get you to watch the body being taken out
Now
Look 1c. How were they able to get those bodies laid out so well on the ground in front of the ovens?, Seems fishy. All I saw in Japan were smaller pieces.
Look at 1d. I feel the oven would not operate properly with that pile of remains. Hot gas comes from the bottom. It seems the remains were shoveled in there? Things that make you go hmmm. If it looks like that inside the oven (1d) shoveled in there, how did they get the remains out and on the ground in front of the ovens so neatly as indicated in photo 1c?
History is never a one-sided story.
Re: My Majdanek Presentation almost completed / now completed
You all know these two tanks from Majdanek Rm 14, see attachment
See this link for another demonstration of the pressure potential in these tanks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0gyBCvcYJI
Feel free to skip ahead to the 2:55 minute mark to save time or watch the whole thing. (In German). I understand the size difference of the tanks
The point here is the piping inside the two rooms or alleged gas chambers is not necessary to gas people with CO gas. A pipe sticking out of the wall will fill the room in seconds with this potential from the tanks.
enjoy
See this link for another demonstration of the pressure potential in these tanks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0gyBCvcYJI
Feel free to skip ahead to the 2:55 minute mark to save time or watch the whole thing. (In German). I understand the size difference of the tanks
The point here is the piping inside the two rooms or alleged gas chambers is not necessary to gas people with CO gas. A pipe sticking out of the wall will fill the room in seconds with this potential from the tanks.
enjoy
History is never a one-sided story.
Return to “'Holocaust' Debate / Controversies / Comments / News”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Otium and 6 guests